Clay & AssociatesAdvocates
  1. Home
  2. Insights
  3. Financial Services

Success Fees Under the Investment and Financial Analysts Act

Clay OdariBy Clay OdariReviewed 6 min readFinancial Services
Success Fees Under the Investment and Financial Analysts Act

Success fees are standard in capital raising and M&A advisory work around the world. In Kenya, investment and financial analysts who are members of the Institute of Certified Investment and Financial Analysts (ICIFA) face a statutory rule that cuts directly across that model. Section 26(1)(k) of the Investment and Financial Analysts Act (Cap. 542) treats fees contingent on results as professional misconduct. This article sets out the rule, who it binds, and the fee structures advisers use in response.

The rule

Section 26(1) lists the acts that make a member of the Institute guilty of professional misconduct. Paragraph (k) covers a member who:

“charges, in respect of any professional employment other than insolvency or receivership, fees which are based on a percentage of profits or which are contingent on results”

Two fee types are caught: fees based on a percentage of profits, and fees contingent on results. A “no cure, no fee” arrangement, where the adviser is paid only if the client raises money or closes a deal, is a fee contingent on results in plain terms. The only exceptions are insolvency and receivership work.

Who the rule binds

Section 26 applies to members of the Institute. It does not, by its terms, bind people who are not members. That creates an uncomfortable position for advisers:

  • Under section 20(1), a person who practises as a certified investment and financial analyst without registration and a practising certificate or annual licence commits an offence, punishable by a fine of up to KES 500,000, imprisonment of up to two years, or both.
  • Section 21(1) defines practice to include offering or performing, for remuneration, services involving investment advice or financial decisions. Capital-raising advice will often fit that description.
  • Once registered, the adviser is a member, and section 26(1)(k) then applies to how the adviser charges.

The salaried employee exemption in section 21(2) does not help an independent adviser. It covers employees acting in that capacity, not a firm charging clients. See our article on when ICIFA registration is needed for who the Act reaches.

A further open question is how the rule applies where the fee is charged by a company rather than an individual. Section 2 defines a firm as a sole proprietorship, partnership or registered company “established by members in practice”, which links the firm to its members. Whether a registered member practising through a company that charges success fees is “charging” those fees for the purposes of paragraph (k) has not, as far as we are aware, been tested. It is a question to put to ICIFA in writing rather than assume.

ICIFA’s own Code of Conduct and Ethics points towards a wide reading. Under the heading “Responsibility for Firm”, it provides that a member in practice who is associated with a firm or corporation as principal, partner, director, officer or shareholder, and has significant influence on its ownership or management, “shall be responsible to the Institute for any failure of such firm or corporation”. A registered head of a firm that charges success fees should therefore assume that ICIFA can hold them answerable for the firm’s fee model, not only for their own invoices.

The wording of paragraph (k) is not unique to analysts. It is copied word for word from section 30(1)(k) of the Accountants Act, 2008, which explains the exception for insolvency and receivership, where contingent fees are normal accountancy practice. The provision was not written with corporate finance in mind. That is a fair point to put to ICIFA, but it does not change the text.

The consequences

Professional misconduct is dealt with by ICIFA’s Disciplinary Committee. Under section 29, the Committee’s recommendations after an inquiry can include a reprimand, publication of the reprimand, costs of up to KES 500,000, a fine of up to KES 1 million, an order to discharge the member’s contractual obligations, suspension of the practising certificate, and cancellation of registration for a set period, including for life.

The contract risk is narrower than the disciplinary risk. Section 26(1)(k) is a disciplinary rule and does not declare contingent fee agreements void. Where Parliament wants that result it says so: section 46(c) of the Advocates Act provides that nothing in that Act gives validity to an advocate’s agreement to be paid only if a suit succeeds. The greater contract risk arises where the adviser practises without the registration the Act requires. In Mapis Investment (K) Ltd v Kenya Railways Corporation [2005] KECA 358 (KLR), the Court of Appeal allowed a defendant to rely on the alleged illegality of an unregistered estate agent’s commission arrangement, applying the principle that no court ought to enforce an illegal contract once the illegality is brought to its notice. We are not aware of a Kenyan decision applying either point to investment advisers.

Fee structures advisers use instead

  • Retainer plus milestone fees. The adviser charges for the work in stages tied to deliverables, such as the financial model, information memorandum, investor list and term sheet. Fees are earned when the work is done, not when the deal closes.
  • Time-based fees with a cap. Fees reflect the time spent, with a cap the client can budget for.
  • Fixed fee per phase. A fixed fee for each phase of the mandate, payable whether or not the client proceeds.
  • Completion fees. A fixed fee payable only on closing is still contingent on results, even if it is not a percentage. It does not avoid paragraph (k) on its own.
  • A written view from ICIFA. Before adopting any variable element, ask the Institute how it applies section 26(1)(k) to corporate finance work. A written answer is more useful than a structure built on assumptions.

Whatever the structure, the engagement letter should describe the services, the basis of each fee and when it falls due, and should not describe a fee as payable “on success” if it is in fact earned on delivery of work. Clients and investors read engagement letters in due diligence, and a fee clause that conflicts with the adviser’s professional rules is a point a counterparty can use later.

Fee sharing raises related issues. Paragraph (c) of section 26(1) prevents a member from paying any share, commission or brokerage out of professional fees to someone who does not hold a practising certificate, which affects paid introducers. Our article on paying introducers covers that rule.

How We Can Help

Clay & Associates Advocates advises advisory firms on fee models, engagement letters and ICIFA and CMA compliance, and can prepare written queries to the regulators. Our overview of no cure, no fee capital raising in Kenya brings the issues together. Contact our Regulatory & Compliance practice to review your fee model.

Sources: Investment and Financial Analysts Act (Cap. 542), sections 2, 20, 21, 26 and 29; ICIFA Code of Conduct and Ethics (June 2017), Responsibility for Firm; Accountants Act, 2008, section 30(1)(k); Advocates Act (Cap. 16), section 46; Mapis Investment (K) Ltd v Kenya Railways Corporation [2005] KECA 358 (KLR).

Frequently asked questions

Can an ICIFA member charge a success fee?

Section 26(1)(k) makes it professional misconduct for a member to charge fees contingent on results or based on a percentage of profits, except in insolvency or receivership work.

Does the rule apply to advisers who are not ICIFA members?

Section 26 binds members. But practising as a certified investment and financial analyst without registration is itself an offence under section 20.

Is a fixed completion fee allowed?

A fee payable only if the deal closes is still contingent on results, even if it is a fixed amount.

What are the penalties for misconduct?

Under section 29, sanctions range from a reprimand to fines of up to KES 1 million, suspension of the practising certificate and cancellation of registration.

Clay & Associates AdvocatesAdvocates, Notaries Public, Commissioners for Oaths and Patent Agents, Nextgen Mall, Mombasa Road, Nairobi.

Need advice on your own matter?

Tell us what you are dealing with. You will know what it involves and what it costs before you commit.

Speak to counsel

This article is general information on Kenyan law as at its publication date, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an advocate and client relationship.